Since I do not have oil filter it seemed a good idea to inspect and clean strainer screen on oil pump as indicated in the book.
So after inspecting and cleaning which did not need much and
After 2 failed attempts to engage the drive tube I am asking for input from anyone who has more experience at re installing them.
I did think it was engaged but oil pressure indicates otherwise.
Thanks in advance.
Jim
This pertains to Series 80 & 81. Jim, I’ve been there and done that, and the thrashing 1/2-inch square tube (replacement at hardware store) broke into several pieces, necessitating dropping the pan. Suggest you remove the six oil pump studs and replace them with capscrews (1/4-20). Pay attention to the length, because three holes are blind and a too-long capscrew will break the pan casting. You will have an additional 3/4 inch to juggle the oil pump body to thread the round pilot tip into the square hole and can feel the drag when the square portion of the pump shaft engages the square tube. I further recommend flat washers and toothed washers under the heads, plus sealant on the threads of the three open-hole capscrews.
Jim,
Years ago, I did as George suggested above.
It makes a HUGE difference in properly placing the oil pump on my Series 80.
I have great oil pressure and do not leak a drop of engine oil.
I don’t recall exactly, but I believe that I made my own gasket from a standard gasket material package that I bought at NAPA.
Peter
George and Peter Thank You. I will try that.
Jim: DON’T do it ! It is not necessary, and can lead to additional problems in the future. I’ll explain lower down this message.
The normal problem with completely missing the square steel drive tube and resulting in no oil pressure: the car is jacked up, it is tilted either to one side, or tipped front to back. The square steel drive tube in the engine swings from a cotter pin through the upper end of the drive tube. So, with the car tilted, the tube does not hang down in the same spot where the oil pump drive shaft is, when the oil pump is held up and the cylindrical screen is lined up with the oil pan opening.
The shaft of the oil pump drive gear has a 1.25″ long round section, before the shaft changes to being square. You have to insert the round portion of the shaft into the square drive tube. You cannot see this insertion, it is 3.5″ up inside the oil pan, it has to be by feel. Once the round shaft is inside the square drive tube, I can feel the ‘rattle’ of the round shaft inside the square tube.
So: my technique: Jack the car up so that it is either lifted at the front, or lifted on the passenger side, Or put the car on a lift, so it is close to level. This minimizes the off-center ‘hang’ of the drive tube. There is more room to maneuver the pump and shaft when the drive shaft is hanging toward the driver’s side, or to the rear.
Hand crank the engine to align the square drive shaft such that one side of the square is parallel to the side of the engine, or the side of the oil pan. Then, hold the oil pump up lining up the pan’s studs with the holes in the pump body. Turn the pump shaft so that it is exactly the same as the drive tube: parallel to the side of the crankcase, or the side of the oil pan.
Put some axle grease on the pump gasket, and push it over the studs, pushing it against the pan’s gasket surface, the grease ‘glues’ the gasket up and in place.
Carefully slide the oil pump up into the oil pan opening, holding it aligned with the mounting studs. You MUST listen and feel for the round end of the oil pump drive shaft to touch the square drive shaft. it can touch on the outside of the tube, or butt up against the end of the tube, or slide inside the tube. You may have to try this several times to finally feel the round shaft inside the square drive tube. When it is inside, I can feel the tube ‘rattle’ around the shaft, and the rattle is the same on all sides of the drive shaft.
Then, continue to slide the pump up, the square of the drive shaft will offer some resistance or friction or ‘feel’ when it slides into the square drive tube. If you did not align the side of the drive tube and the pump drive shaft correctly, the shaft will not slide up into the drive tube.
If the pump drive shaft does not align with the square drive, there will be about 1/4″ of space or clearance between the end of the studs and the oil pump gasket surface. If the studs have been removed, this clearance will be about 3/4″. Any clearance is enough. Excess clearance does not help aligning the two squares, since that alignment is 3.5″ up, inside the oil pan, near the oil pan gasket surface.
The reason to not remove the studs is that then, each time the pump is dropped for cleaning the screen and wiping the bottom of the oil pan, the bolts will be wearing against the threads in the soft aluminum of the oil pan.
This is a significant problem. The studs are double threaded: 5/16″x18 coarse thread for the part threaded into the soft aluminum pan and 5/16″x24 threads for the pump retaining nuts. The reason is that the aluminum is SOFT, and the coarse threads are needed so that each thread is thicker and stronger. Pierce designed the studs and fasteners this way because the early aluminum was very soft, and does not take cross threading, or frequent tightening of a bolt very well. The threads being soft will wear rapidly from use. A stud is threaded in once, and usually sealed in place.
I have removed and replaced the oil pump on S80/81 engines with the original studs, and also with the studs removed, and short bolts replacing the studs. The insertion of the round drive shaft and the alignment of the square shape of each is not easier, at least not to me. And not having the studs to assist holding the gasket with grease up, out of the way makes the no-studs setup almost as difficult as with studs.
And, there is the very real problem with removing the steel studs that have been in the aluminum pan for nearly a century. Often they break off, then you have to drill them out, and put a Heli-coil or other thread repair insert in the pan. This is very difficult to do well when the pan is on the engine. I’d probably remove the oil pan if I found a broken stud, or stripped oil pan threads.
Try following the technique i outlined above. You will get it back together.
Oh, by the way, I’ve had to remove and re-try the insertion and alignment of the shaft and tube several times. it can be a bit frustrating. Persevere, there is no ‘easy out’.
Hope this helps.
Greg Long
Thanks Greg. I have broken at least my share of bolts and studs and that is being careful and ends up being a chore to repair. So will first keep trying. the front of car is up about 5″ will try raising passenger side also but won’t get back to it until next week/Year
Happy New Year!
Jim”
Jim,
With all due respect to Greg’s significant mechanical prowess, I offer these comments.
Liberal amounts of PB Blaster (two or three times, a few days in advance), a touch of heat to the tips of the studs and a GOOD Stud Pulling Socket, should do the trick to remove the studs without a break.
You will likely not do this again in your lifetime, so wear on the threaded part of the aluminum crankcase caused by hex-head screws / bolts is not really an issue.
Also, if you use your brain, after removing the studs, you will measure the depth of the blind holes in the crankcase and determine the thickness of the base of the oil pump.
If you then buy hex-head machine screws / bolts that are slightly shorter than your full depth, including pump base thickness and lock washers, you will not reach the blind end of the bolt hole and will not crack the crankcase from inserting and torquing too long of a bolt.
Finally, if you do this prep work, the oil pump will just go in like a charm.
Proper Project Preparation Prevents Piss Poor Performance (the Seven Ps for Success).
Cheers,
Peter
Jim,
Also, if you have a spare oil pan, you can always do the stud removal program on the spare and then swap pans.
Peter
Peter: With all that ‘work’. Why not just learn how to install the pump? I was done in the past, it can be done again, and again. Why risk broken studs, cracked oil pans, stripped threads ?
You just have to think, look, and do.
And even with the studs removed, and using cap screws [short bolts] it STILL requires some finesse. I”ve pulled and replaced the oil pumps on George’s engines more than once, and it still can be done wrong, or it can fight you.
Greg
Oh boy, I wanted to refrain from further beating of this dead horse, BUT…
Greg, when you worked on my two 80s, I had done so previously and BOTH had capscrews rather than the original studs but you made no comments then. And Percy the coupe’s capscrews were installed by Eric Rosenau and Bill Lawton during their restoration of the car for Phelps Chamberlain in 1983. That’s where I got the idea for replacing the studs in Humphrey the sedan circa 1994. I’d renewed my early 1960s friendship with the Chamberlains after acquiring the semi-project sedan, and spent a lot of time under their car until they offered it to me in 1995.
Greg is right about keeping the car level, especially left to right, and best if all four corners are raised. PAMCC engineers were right in their original design in the days before detergent multi-grade oil, in which pulling the oil pump for cleaning the screen, pump and pan was a far more frequent task than today.
In sum, today it’s a question of whether one follows the factory practice or implements a Field Expedient to get the job done satisfactorily. Either will do the job just fine. Now how many angels can dance on the head of an oil pump mounting stud?
George,
I believe that the number of angels that can dance on the head of an oil pump stud depends upon whether they are dancing a Waltz, a Fox Trot or the Charleston.
Regardless, the number is somewhere infinitely north of Avogadro’s number, which is of course, 6.022140857 × 10 to the 23rd.
Peter
Peter,
Avocado number? What do I care about the number of atoms in a mole? They are pesky little lawn pests. The only Avocado number I care about is the price per pound.
Dilly, Dilly
Bob
DING DING DING DING……..just under the wire we have a winner for the most outstanding thread hijacking of 2018!!
Tony,
Thank You!
Peter
Bob,
Dilly, Dilly back at you!
Peter
I am very happy and relieved to report that oil pump is now pumping and I did not remove the studs. so thanks to Pierce Engineers for a workable design and to Greg for encouraging another (4th) try!!
Thanks to all for your remarks. They were EDUCATIONAL, HELPFUL, AND ENTERTAINING!!
Happy New Year!
Jim
Hi George, back on track for Jim’s original post.
I did not mention your missing studs because I didn’t like the cap-screws. And chasing down the short, odd-thread studs was not something i wanted to do.
With studs, or without, the alignment of the pump shaft and the square drive tube can be difficult, and frustrating. I do not like removing perfectly good steel studs from an aluminum item. Steel and aluminum get real ‘friendly’ over a few decades, and even though the inside of the stud is bathed in oil, the steel studs often gaul the threads, requiring a thread repair.
The studs are lubricated pretty well, they have had decades of hot engine oil circulating past the inside end of the stud, or hot engine oil seeping through the gasket keeping the stud and threads soaked in oil. so no amount of penetrating oil is going to make the stud easier to remove. The stud is a virtual interference-fit thread. VERY tight. This is for sealing and making the threads seal, and the stud stay put.
My original comments to Jim were to point out that the removal of the studs is problem-prone, can cause much additional work, and all for ?? A slightly easier pump install.
Removing the studs and using cap screws is not a panacea for a fool-proof installation of the oil pump. Not by a long-shot.
Greg
The image is of an oil pan I have with half the studs broken off,
Jim: Great News !! Glad to hear your wonderful Touring car is back on the road !!
Greg Long